Rut Phire Par din Hamare Phire Na (Pyaasa, 1957)

One of the self-imposed rules of this blog, which I have just now recognised, is that – Thou shalt write a long post on at least one Sahir Ludhianvi song per week. This realisation came about as I heard an old favourite play on the radio a short while ago. I try not to listen to the FM channels while on the road. I am not too fond of the cacophony that passes off as music these days. No Yo Yo Honey Singhs or even the more melodious Arijit Singhs for me, thank you very much.

So a couple of hours back, I was very pleasantly surprised when I heard that rare Geeta Dutt song from PyaasaRut Phire Par Din Hamare Phire Na.

Pyaasa, the 1957 Guru Dutt classic starring Guru Dutt, Mala Sinha and Waheeda Rehman, boasted of memorable music. The brilliant music was composed by S.D. Burman and the classic lyrics were penned by Sahir Ludhianvi. This was to be the last movie of this lyricist- music composer duo.

Each number is a legendary song in itself and requires a separate post for its lyrics, music, singing and picturisation. There is the lilting Geeta Dutt solo, picturised on a coquettish Gulabo (Waheeda), Jaane Kya Tune Kahi and the number in the Baul tradition, Aaj Sajan Mohe Ang Laga Lo Janam Safal Ho Jaaye. Then there is the haunting Hemant Kumar lament Jaane Woh Kaise Log Thhe, where Vijay the poet (Guru Dutt) comes face to face with his former lover who abandoned him to marry Rehman (Vijay’s current employer). One cant help contrast this with Sahir’s Chalo Ek Baar Phir se from Gumrah, where the context is similar yet different. There is the very romantic Mohd Rafi -Geeta Dutt duet, Hum Aapki Aankhon Mein Is Dil Ko. Or the Johnny Walker’s famous Tel Maalish gaana, Sar Jo Tera Chakraye, Ya dil dooba Jaaye.   And of course, there are the hard hitting Rafi solos where Sahir’s cynicism is very evident and the music by SDB is in tandem to highlight the plight of the society as seen by the poet, Vijay – Yeh Duniya Agar Mil Bhi Jaaye toh Kya Hai and the Jinhein Naaz Hai Hind Pe woh Kahan hai.

Each and every song in this legendary movie can be dissected in adequate detail. This post however is about that one number which never made it on screen. Rut Phire Par Din Hamare was not there in the movie. In Nasreen Munni Kabir’s book (Conversations with Waheeda Rehman), the topic of this song comes. According to Waheeda, this song had been filmed with her rowing in a boat and everyone had appreciated the picturisation. However Waheeda Rehman differed with the view and she apparently pointed out that having that song slows the pace of the story and is just boring. Guru Dutt had heard her criticism and after the first screening, had agreed with her observation (seeing people walk out for a bathroom or coffee break), had taken it off.

Coming to the song, it is one of Geeta Dutt’s finest songs (in my opinion). The plaintiveness of the song comes through in her melancholic rendition of it – Seasons may come and go, but her days never do; her life is much the same. The fate of the world may be looking up and the earth may be becoming brighter, but her life is filled with just the same darkness day in and day out. The futility of her life and situation is brilliantly summed up. She is in the middle of a river – with nothing to look forward to on either bank.

It is a pity that the filmed song (even though unused in the film) hasnt been made available to the public. Redundant it may have been in terms of the narrative of the movie, but it would have been good to see this wonderful number on a beautiful Waheeda Rehman!




5 thoughts on “Rut Phire Par din Hamare Phire Na (Pyaasa, 1957)

  1. What a lovely song this is: I do wish it were possible to see the filmed version. (Reminds me of another Waheeda Rehman song that was axed: Jaata kahaan hai deewaane from CID).

    Talking of Sahir writing for Pyaasa, while I like all the songs – especially Yeh duniya agar mil bhi jaaye – my favourite (without any music, which is probably why most people forget about it) is the hauntingly bitter Tang aa chuke hain kashmakash-e-zindagi se hum. So poignant, and so wonderfully rendered by Rafi.

    Oh, I could go on and on about Sahir. 🙂

    1. Oh yes – Jaata Kahan Hai deewane was such a tuneful, melodious song 🙂 Pity, that such lovely songs got axed.

      Sahir… hmm! What can one say about him? Sabhi alfaaz bahut kam hain. He was a genius. Please do go on and on.. 🙂

      Had completely forgotten about Tang Aa Chuke Hain as being a part of Pyaasa. Maybe because as you said, it is without any music. I need to watch the movie again.

      I just remember the N. Dutta composition sung by Asha Bhosle in the film Lighthouse (1958). (

      This is one of the Nutan films of that period, I haven’t yet watched. So wonder what the context is and how it is picturised. It is interesting how the same ghazal has been used in two different movies (made in the same period – hardly a year apart).

  2. I’ve never heard this before! What a lovely song. Someone, somewhere should have the video to this song. I hope they’ll make it available. It is sad how old Hindi films never seem to have a “director’s cut” version. (I only know of Sholay where the director’s cut had a slightly different ending from the original release.)

    Like Dustedoff, I coud also go on and on about Sahir and his writing for Pyaasa. Every time I hear a song from this film, it is my “favorite” in the film, till I hear the next… And now there is Rut phiri par din humare as well.

    1. Oh yes, I was wondering the same – someone somewhere should have this video! It is an absolutely lovely song!

      Sahir is amazing – one can go on and on about him; I didn’t realise this when I was younger but each and every song I have liked very much is by this man.

      Thanks! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s